Which rules for the Back of Beyond or the Russian Civil War? There was an overlap what with the Mad White Baron and simply geography. The hobby has reached the stage that a glossy set of rules exists for many a theatre.
So said Aodh Mhor O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone when asked to provide his son as a hostage. It came to mind as we modern folk approach another watershed in the onward march of history. It also coincides with my new found interest in the Great Northern War. So, I chose it as a blog title.
Which rules for the Back of Beyond or the Russian Civil War? There was an overlap what with the Mad White Baron and simply geography. The hobby has reached the stage that a glossy set of rules exists for many a theatre.
Interests can lie dormant and then spring up demanding time
and attention. This time it is the War of the Roses (WOTR). That’s in general
and specifically the Fitzgerald v Ormond feud.
One thing invariably leads to another and I think on unit
composition. A great bugbear of the WOTR. We don’t know enough to be sure. We
do know enough to argue.
My own take is that they were mixed. Especially if we are
talking Billhooks or Rampant small battle stuff. Skirmish even.
Alright let’s get fiddly. Take a unit of 12 figures of which
4 are men at arms. There might be 8 Billmen. Or, 4 archers and 4 Billmen. Or 2
Men at arms and 10 Archers. I’ll stop there but you get the point.
When it comes to shooting 4 Archers shoot. When it comes to fighting each of our 3 types inflict hits at a different rate. Men at arms hit on a 3, Billmen on a 5 and Archers on a 6. How to do this expediently?
Use a different colour dice for each type and there you go. I know, fiddly but it bespeaks of additional fun.
Unit cost? Each figure has a notional value, just do the sums. Two Men at Arms cost 2 points, 6 Billmen cost 2 points, 6 Archers cost 2 points. A 6 points a unit but doable.
Not only that but you get to make a decision on whether your unit excels at shooting or the close up stuff.
Of course you can just make them
all of one type. That's where we came in with Rampant and Billhooks. Pleasingly both are very flexible systems.
Anyhow, here are my new units. Top of the page the Earl of Kildare and his horsemen. Below, with his men on foot.
This is a bit of an odd post. Bear with me and we will get there.
When Andy Callan's Never Mind the Billhooks arrived I was impressed. I reviewed it here. You can see that if you click the Billhooks tag. At about the same time QRF launched a WOTR range that you see on this page.
Here we have (12) Percy Bowmen in correct livery colours and crescent badge. Peter Pig fig's. We are going to need some Neville's. It's all Percy so far.
First, the
majority of Irish soldiers were Gaels and they wore trews not breeches and hose. Khurasan Miniatures gets it
right and I’m using their figures.
Some Clans had
been dispersed. Others waited for the inevitable dispossession of their
ancestral lands. The land was full of men ready to soldier. They lacked arms
and training. Once these were available armies formed. The new soldiers went to
war in what the stood up in. Uniforms were not provided.
At the top of
the page is Eoghan Ruadh O’Neill back from Spanish Flanders. I have chosen to
paint "Red Owen" in red, replete with Red Hand flag of his clan. He wears a traditional
fringed Brat cloak to remind the boys what they are fighting for. Otherwise he
is dressed like a Spanish soldier as is his companion. Many of the Irish officers
had seen foreign service and were attired as such.
The rank and
file soldiers and junior officers wore Irish clothing. I find a set of WW2
paints come in very handy here. The subdued colours lend themselves nicely to this army.
Above we see a
Command Stand of an Irish regiment. In reality the kinsmen of the commander
would be grouped around him. The man himself has a buff coat, his clothes are
colourful. He has a morion helmet, perhaps hidden for decades. Or maybe newly acquired. The drummer is well dressed in good quality trews and a coloured coat. The piper is more simply attired.
His pikemen will repay scrutiny. Two are wearing expensive plaid trews requiring much time and
labour to make. Robust wear for campaigning. Otherwise one has a sword and two
have a scÃan (Long Knife). The scian was handier for
pike fighting but the sword carried more prestige. The flag is that of the Irish Confederation that claimed the allegiance of Gaels and Old English both. This is a Wargames Designs Flag.
Let us take a table, a famous one. It is called A
Description Of The Power Of Irishmen. It lists the military resources of each Irish
Lordship. It is a piece of English intelligence work usually dated to the early
C16th. Gresh gives us the true date (1490) of the document and tells us how he
knows. This nicely sets the tone for the book. I should say the martial resources of the Towns and the Great Earls
are also detailed. The Englishry, as it were. A contrast to the Irishry of the
Gaels.
Importantly, Gresh begins with how Irish Society worked. The law was massively different from that in England, as was the social structure. This approach enables us to understand how and why things happened. When we are in the 20 mile deep Pale, English Law pertained. Hence Beyond the Pale.
If Ireland was politically decentralised its concepts were unified.
It knew itself to be an ancient culture and indeed was in the throes of
a cultural revival. If the Lords of Ireland appeared like figures out of
history that, Gresh notes, is precisely what they intended.
The Great Earls (Old English) were speaking Irish, employing
Brehon Lawyers, Gallowglass and Kern. I have
written of them before in the Hibernia section of Billhooks. Gresh takes them
in turn and in detail. These were the proto Macmorris of Shakespeare’s later confection. Ostensibly
Irish, but politically English in allegiance.
I’ll note that
Fitzgerald of Kildare had the motto “Crom Aboo” on his standard. An anglicisation
of “Crom Abú”. Gresh, correctly tells us that “Crom” refers to Croom Castle a
Geraldine stronghold. Abú simply meaning “Up” or “Uber Alles” if you like. Literally "above".
Yet, in the middle of the Gaelic Resurgence it was known
that Crom, Lord of the Mound, was one of the Old God’s. An old God linked with death.
Was this Geraldine humour?
He does not give us the big picture. You can find that readily enough elsewhere. He does give us the definitive volume on the Ireland's military prior to O’Neill’s gunpowder revolution and the Nine Years War.
Colour plates are by Séan O’ Brógáin, a treat
as ever. You see two above. An extensive 10 page bibliography completes the work.
Robert Gresh is a participant in Wilde Irish a Living
History Group. You can find them online. He has accomplished something rather
special with "Of Kerns and Gallowglasses". I commend it to you.
One of Helion's best so far. Inspirational? Most certainly. As we shall see in coming weeks and months.