Followers

Showing posts with label Never Mind The Billhooks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Never Mind The Billhooks. Show all posts

Thursday, February 16, 2023

The Scots at Flodden


Now the additional figures have come from QRF. I can finally get some units completed.  Above James King of Scots.  

Above, the Guilds and levies of Edinburgh.  Note the very nice flags from Ray at Don't Throw a 1.  The first flag shows St. Margaret who began life as a Northumbrian princess.  She married the King of Scots. 

Next, I need to do the Earl Marischall's retinue.  That will give me three units for the Scots centre. And the guns of course.

The Scots artillery, 3 guns in all.

More pike men.

The Men of the Borders under the Home and Maxwell banners.


With Highland flank guard under a Gordon flag. I need to add another Highland unit for the Borderers other flank.


On the other side of the central units there will be more Highlanders.  One unit is done and another is in preparation.  Below, you see Clan Campbell.
 

Both of these will be full Clan levies.  The well armed Nobles and gentry supported by less well armed clansmen.
 


There we are, three units to go, one of pike men and two of Highlanders. In time I'll add some Border Horse too.  I have the figures already.  Baring a few that I'll badge with the St. Andrews or St. George's crosses the rest will be interchangable. As they were in life.

Monday, January 9, 2023

Berbers for Billhooks

 


There are of course Berbers and Berbers.  I’m thinking of Berbers in Spain.  Of course, Berbers are and were Berber, with Berber military traditions.  A quick look at Moorish and Numidian forces in ancient days shows the roots of that tradition.  Broadly speaking I’m going to end up with a list of units rather than a specific army list.   

 

This is my thinking so far.

When the ground was right, restrictive to cavalry and close formation troops, massed Berber skirmishers could attack in waves hurling javelins at close range.  On one such occasion they lured veteran Arab cavalry into dismounting to pursue them into difficult ground.  The Berbers then attacked destroying the Arab force.

 

On open ground other tactics were required and found. These revolved around the veiled spear men you see above.

Some tribes enjoyed a better military reputation than others.  Unfair?  Maybe.  It does allow us to vary the rating of units.  For example, we might have:

 

Veteran Berber spear men or Levy Berber spear men.  The veterans might be Retinue in Billhooks terms.   


Berber spear men might also be in a block with a second rank of archers.  The archers might be levy or might not.  A third rank of cavalry stood behind the archers.  Importantly, the cavalry could advance directly through both lines of infantry when the time came for a counter attack.


Sub Saharan troops loom large in Berber Armies.   


They might be mercenaries and so retinue.  Or, military slaves and so possibly not.   

They could be spear men or archers or a highly rated Black Guard unit. I've just ordered a unit of the latter because...El Cid.

 


Berber skirmishers were very good.  Fortunately, Billhooks already provides for such fellows.  I’ll use the Kern stat’s. Often such Berber infantry formed a second line behind the spear men and threw javelins over their heads.  The spear men leveled their spears, butts firmly grounded and knelt behind their shields to facilitate that.  This means we should allow our Berber skirmishers to form up to carry out that function.

That leads us nicely to Berber tactics in set piece battle.  The light cavalry deployed on the wings or in front of the army.  The light infantry was on the flanks.  The centre was formed of spear men with supporting archers or javelin throwers.  Behind this more cavalry waited.

The idea was to absorb the enemy charge and counter charge when they were disordered.  On occasion this was combined with a flank attack.

If you are interested in the Crusades, you might now be thinking “Just like the Fatimid’s battle tactics.” A moment later you might add "and Frankish tactics in Outremer".

This raises the interesting question were all Berber cavalry light skirmishers?  I don’t know the answer.  I can say that Berber cavalry in Fatimid armies did not skirmish but fought hand to hand.

Here is another thing, Berber armies could manoeuvre in response to drum signals. I think that calls for a special card.  My take is simple, the card will allow the whole army to advance or retire a single move.  It can be played once in a game.

That’s it so far.  More soon.

Monday, December 5, 2022

Flodden English Nobles

 


While I'm waiting for more QRF Scots I'm pressing on with the English.  Above we have Sir Thomas Howard, Lord Admiral and Earl of Surrey.  He is accompanied by a retainer carrying his personal banner.  The retainer wears Tudor livery.  King Henry paid for 500 such livery coats for Surrey's men.  

Behind him are two English nobles and more of Howard's men with his Lord Admiral banner.  This unit will form the centre of the English array at Flodden.  The flags are all from Ray at Don't Throw a 1.  If you are Flodden inclined click the link in the side bar and then check out Flodden flags.  You can also read Lord Scrope's Ballad while you are there.

Let's have a closer look at Lord Scrope.  Doughty fellow that he was.  


That he inspired a Border ballad was no mean accolade, . Here he sports his heraldic arms, a practice shortly to exit fashion.  His retainers wear his white livery colour.


Next, we have Sir Marmaduke Constable his men wearing his red livery.

 

A closer pic' of the Lord Admiral.


Howard's achievement at Flodden was remarkable.  Had the battle gone the other way it is possible to imagine a very different future For England, Ireland and Scotland.  This is seldom recognised.  It deserves to be.


I also managed to get a unit of archers done.  They wear Tudor or Scrope's livery-so a lot of white.  This unit would also work for the English in France too. Note the flag from Army Royal blog-link in the side bar.

Next I need to do a unit of Bill men and the Lord Admiral's Marines.  The latter are very well harnessed troops.

 


 


Sunday, November 20, 2022

Billhooks Deluxe is here

 

Billhooks Deluxe is out today.  At Andy Callan’s invitation I wrote the Hibernia chapter.  Consequently I got a copy last week.  It has first rate production values as you might expect from the Wargames Illustrated team. There are 180 pages of interesting and wide ranging content.  Reasonably priced too.  I think it will prove very popular.  


Anyhow, as a contributor I’m obviously not an independent reviewer so you must look elsewhere for that.  If you want to read my unbiased review of the original Billhooks here it is https://youdonotknowthenorth.blogspot.com/2020/08/never-mind-billhooks-review-and-irish.html   As team projects go Billhooks Deluxe was very straight forward. It was a pleasure to be involved.

 

I want to talk about Billhooks as a tool kit.  Like all good systems it is adaptable. For me this means my Crusades Game, the Flodden Campaign, The Spanish Reconquista, The Nine Years War in Ireland and my Aztec Game. That may seem an eclectic list.  Let me explain further.

 

My Crusades adaptation followed the initial Billhooks release. As a game it works nicely.  I’m currently talking with Andy on how to take it forward.  Meantime expect a couple of Crusades game reports here.

All the troop types needed for the Flodden Campaign are to found in Billhooks Deluxe.  There is not a specific Flodden chapter but that is no obstacle.  QRF have relisted the figures I need so hopefully not long now.  I'll add the various Tudor Rebellions and the Anglo French 1513 conflict are all doable with Billhooks too.

The Spanish Reconquista has long interested me and I think most of the troop types are contained in Billhooks Deluxe.  I have some ideas about Berbers that I want to explore.  Of course the Reconquista was a long process. More on this as I go.

 

I’m currently thinking about an adaptation of Billhooks for the Nine Years War in Ireland.  Some of the troop types are already there and the paired formations system is very compatible. As is the manouvre phase. All the same a big leap.  Will it work?  I think so.  I should say Irish tactics and armament in the Nine Years War were very different from those used in the medieval period.


You may recall I did a lot of work on Aztec Warfare and then got stuck.  I had a sudden Billhooks related insight on how to move forward.  The key game issue is how to ensure sufficient jeopardy for the Spanish.  Hopefully I’ll have more to say on this soon.

 

That’s Billhooks Deluxe, I like it and foresee a lot of fun ahead.  The toys shown here are mainly from QRF's Wars of The Roses range.  Well worth a look if you fancy doing the Wars of the Roses.

Monday, July 25, 2022

Flodden Project -An update

 

Above we have James, King of Scots.  He is a converted QRF dismounted gendarme, his comrades are from the same stable.  I gave him a green stuff   "Base".  The "Base" is the wee skirt thing and added a pike.

 

I cannot complete this unit until QRF fully restocks.  The same applies to the unit below. I'll show the completed units when I can.

Scots archers, there were none, bar Highlanders, at Flodden. There were a few about all the same.  Probably my last Scots unit until the re stock.  That said, I might manage the burgesses of Edinburgh.

Luckily, I have English galore to be getting on with. 


The Earl of Essex's contingent here.  All from QRF.  Later, we will see some Khurasan figures.  The two are happily compatible.

The Earl's standard is from Pete's Flags. That of the archers is one of Ray's flags.  The latter St. George's flag shows Tudor allegiance by virtue of the roses.  

The Earl of Norfolk's men here.  

Flags sourced ditto.  

QRF figures once again. 

Here are the men of York.  Note the City banner and the flag of the Holy Trinity both from Ray at Don't Throw a 1. 

  

We will be seeing the Holy Trinity flag again carried by Northern contingents.  Also, The Five Wounds of Christ one ditto.

 

You can probably guess where I am considering going.  Project creep, as ever.  If we get there we might have a look at northern English attitudes back then.  

Note the illustration below. The banner of St. Cuthbert (Sacred battle icon of the North) and a Percy standard.  Percy flags are easily sourced. Ray has one and a nice St. Cuthbert one too.

The game plan so far is like this.  A core of Royal English troops in green on white livery, say 4 or 5 units. All from Khurasan. Followed by six units of Northern troops and four to six others contingents. 

Now, we may not get that far.  I have bothered to take a period political refresher so there are grounds for optimism.

More Bill Hooks 2 fun shortly.